Why Your Dog’s Behavior Has Nothing to Do With Stubbornness

I hear it all the time:
“My dog knows what I want… they’re just being stubborn.”
“He listens at home but ignores me outside. He’s so defiant.”
“She’s testing me. She’s being difficult on purpose.”

It’s easy to believe that your dog is intentionally disobeying you. After all, you’ve seen them sit when they want a treat or come when it’s convenient. So when they don’t respond in more challenging moments, it feels personal.

But here’s the truth: your dog’s behavior is almost never about stubbornness. It’s about clarity, leadership, and context. And when you shift your perspective, everything changes.

Why “Stubborn” Isn’t the Problem

What looks like stubbornness is usually:

• A lack of understanding

• A lack of proofing in different environments

• A lack of consistent follow-through from the handler

• Or a dog who has learned that ignoring you works

Dogs do what works for them. If ignoring a command gets them what they want—or if they’ve never truly learned what you expect—they’re not being defiant. They’re just being dogs.

And that’s good news. Because it means the behavior isn’t fixed—it’s fixable.

Let’s Break It Down

1. Your Dog Might Understand… in Context

Dogs don’t generalize well. Just because your dog knows “come” in the kitchen doesn’t mean they know it at the park. The environment changes everything—distractions, smells, energy.

🛠 Fix it: Train in a variety of settings. Don’t assume understanding until you’ve practiced with distraction, distance, and duration.

2. Your Timing Might Be Inconsistent

If your correction comes too late… or your reward doesn’t align with the behavior you wanted… your dog gets mixed messages.

🛠 Fix it: Work on timing and clarity. Say the command once. Pause. Follow through. Reward what you want in the moment it happens.

3. Your Energy Might Be Sending Mixed Signals

Are you nervous? Frustrated? Rushing? Your dog is reading you more than they’re listening to you. When you’re unclear or emotionally reactive, they feel that—and respond accordingly.

🛠 Fix it: Ground yourself before engaging. Show up with calm, confident leadership. That alone will shift your dog’s behavior.

4. You Might Be Reinforcing the Wrong Thing

Unknowingly rewarding pushy behavior (with attention), repeating commands, or giving up halfway through all teach your dog what they can get away with.

🛠 Fix it: Be intentional. Follow through every time. Reward calm. Interrupt pushiness. Be the version of yourself your dog can rely on.

Your Dog Isn’t Giving You a Hard Time—They’re Having a Hard Time

This shift in perspective is powerful. It moves you out of blame and into leadership. It softens frustration and invites curiosity. And it builds the kind of relationship where training becomes a collaboration, not a battle of wills.

Final Thoughts: From Frustration to Clarity

The moment you stop labeling your dog as “stubborn,” you open the door to real progress. Because it’s not about willpower—it’s about communication. Not about dominance—it’s about direction.

📩 Join my email list for weekly insights on leadership-based training that actually works.
🎧 Listen to my podcast, Life Lessons from Dog for real-world stories and reflections that go deeper than obedience. Subscribe here.
🐕 Need help moving past the frustration? Let’s work together. Book a session or enroll in my e-collar program. Schedule here.
📖 Follow the blog for more lessons, strategies, and stories from the leash.

Because once you stop seeing your dog as stubborn, you start seeing what they really need: your leadership.